A lot of the rhetoric around prediction markets is a bit much for my taste. But a new angle from proponents of the nascent industry needs some more formal pushback.
A group representing some companies in the prediction markets industry is saying it’s ridiculous to assert that they would ever try to offer casino games:
The thread from the Coalition for Prediction Markets (CPM) on Twitter went on to cite a Politico story that references comments made to the CFTC:
The Coalition for Prediction Markets, whose members include Kalshi, Crypto.com and Coinbase, wrote in a letter Thursday to the Commodity Futures Trading Commission that it would support a new rule expressly banning prediction markets from offering products linked to “traditional casino games” like slot machines, roulette and table games.
Kalshi’s Head of Corporate Development Sara Slane called the concept that a prediction market would offer casino games “fear-mongering”:
OK, that’s fantastic. No casino games at prediction markets! We’ll definitely take your word for it.
Once upon a time, Kalshi’s own litigation position treated sports-event contracts as an obvious example of “gaming” that the CFTC could rein in. In its federal court case against the CFTC over election contracts, Kalshi drew a bright line between elections and sports. Election contracts, Kalshi argued, were not gaming. Sports-event contracts, by contrast, were the kind of thing Congress had in mind when it gave the CFTC authority to review and prohibit event contracts involving “gaming.” Here’s Kalshi in a brief in that case:
Indeed, according to the CFTC itself, the ‘gaming’ category encompasses contracts based on sporting events. … And contracts contingent on sports betting are not hypothetical (See CFTC Release No. 8345-20, CFTC Announces Review of RSBIX NFL Futures Contracts Proposed by Eris Exchange, LLC (Dec. 23, 2020) (contracts predicated on point spreads and total points in NFL games). The only relevant legislative history, moreover, confirms that contracts on “sporting events such as the Super Bowl, the Kentucky Derby, and Masters Golf Tournament” were precisely what Congress had in mind as “gaming” contracts.
And here’s counsel for Kalshi in oral argument for that case in district court:
Our core point is really simple: Gaming requires a game. So if there’s no underlying game, there’s no gaming. And so for example, if you have a contract on who’s going to win the Kentucky Derby, that’s a game. It’s a horse race, it’s a game. If you have an event contract on who’s going to win the Super Bowl or the point spread in the Super Bowl, it involves a game. There’s an underlying game. Same thing with the lottery. They have an underlying game that forms the basis for the contract. Again, the fight is about what does gaming mean in this statutory context. Our core point is really simple: Gaming requires a game. So if there’s no underlying game, there’s no gaming. …
Number two, I think is most consistent with the text. The root word of gaming is game. I think it aligns with the legislative history, the famous colloquy that gets a lot of discussion in the briefing between Senators Feinstein and Lincoln -- which by the way, if Your Honor wants to watch it on C-SPAN, you won’t be able to find it. I think it was inserted in writing after the fact. It wasn’t literally a colloquy, but you can see it in the congressional record, and they give three examples of gaming contracts: Football, horseracing and golf. They’re all games. I don’t think that’s an accident. I think that interpretation makes sense too, because what is a game? It’s something that has no inherent economic significance. It’s something that is done for amusement. It may be done for sport. It may be done purely to facilitate the betting itself, right, for its own sake.
So I think it makes sense for Congress to have thought about that category. Contracts that involve games are probably not the type of contracts that we want to be listed on an exchange, because they don’t have any real economic value to them. But again, what’s tying that together is the existence of the game because the game is the thing that doesn’t have intrinsic economic significance.
In any event, it’s pretty clear and established by the record that Kalshi drew a line between election contracts and sports-event contracts. It argued the former was fine and the latter should be considered “gaming.”
Fast-forward to today; we all know what happened. Kalshi now generates billions of dollars in trading volume on sports events every week.
Now, Kalshi et al. are asking us to treat the idea of casino-style prediction markets as absurd — and to trust that no one in the industry would try to go there.
Look, most of us did not assume the Commodity Exchange Act and Dodd-Frank Act would become the legal framework for sports-event contracts that look, to many people, a lot like sports betting. Kalshi itself may well have been in that camp, given what it argued in the election-contract case. So I’m sorry if some of us are skeptical when the industry now says no one would ever dream of trying the same move with casino-style products.
There’s no guarantee that the CFTC will enact a rule about “gaming” applying to casino games. And even if CPM’s members stick to their position, there is no guarantee that prediction-market operators outside the group will not try to offer casino-style products.
Meanwhile, CFTC Chairman Mike Selig is not exactly slamming the door on casino-like event contracts, nor promising that a rule would be written to address it! From Front Office Sports:
“Because to the extent there are products that look more like a casino product, we might consider different rules for that, or decide not to allow those products.”
Is it fear-mongering to say a prediction-market company would try to offer something that looked like a casino game? Given the history, I don’t think it is.
You can’t pause current events when your payments can’t keep up. With every failed deposit or lengthy withdrawal process, customers lose trust in your brand. And when money doesn’t move fast enough, your liquidity suffers. PayNearMe’s PayXMTMplatform is purpose-built for Payment Experience Management, giving you the fast, familiar payment options your customers want while streamlining back-end operations for your team. Get real-time payments for real-time events—from one simple integration.
Prediction markets roundup
🚨 The important stuff
-
Pappas Calls for U.S. House to Subpoena Prediction Markets, Fully Investigate Corruption and Insider Trading (press release): Today Congressman Chris Pappas (NH-01) called on Congressman James Comer (KY-01), the Chairman of the House Committee on Oversight, to formally open an investigation into corruption and insider trading occurring in online prediction markets by subpoenaing internal records from these markets.
-
Online prediction markets allow individuals to gamble on the outcomes of a wide variety of real-life events, including sports games, election outcomes, daily stock and commodity price changes, whether certain legislation being considered by Congress will be signed into law, and even geopolitical events such as the likelihood of the United States taking military action against another country or the outcome of diplomatic negotiations.
-
In his letter, Pappas highlighted how recent wagers on political and international topics have raised suspicion of insider trading, writing: “As you know there have been a number of suspicious trades made in connection with U.S. and Israeli military operations against Iran... a single trader made nearly $1 million with a 93 percent success rate on wagers predicting unannounced U.S. and Israeli military operations against Iran, placing bets hours before strikes in October 2024, June 2025, and February 2026. A separate group of 38 accounts netted more than $2 million on the February 28 strikes alone, after being preloaded with funds the preceding week. At least 50 newly created accounts placed coordinated bets on a U.S.-Iran ceasefire on April 7, some opened minutes before the announcement.”
-
He went on to highlight the vested interest of the American people in knowing whether government officials are using these markets in violation of the law and their oaths of office: “The American public has a legitimate interest in knowing whether individuals entrusted with classified national security information have used that access for personal financial gain. A committee investigation, enforced with subpoenas, will include internal records, which are the only means by which the individuals who conducted these trades can be identified and the question of whether these platforms are upholding their responsibilities can be answered. Congress has both the authority and the responsibility to determine whether existing ethics, classification, and financial disclosure laws have been violated, and whether legislative action is necessary to prevent recurrence.”
-
Pappas concluded by re-emphasizing the importance of House Oversight’s subpoena power, noting: “We cannot fulfill that responsibility without knowing who placed these trades.”
-
Coverage from The Hill: “Democratic Reps. Maggie Goodlander (N.H.), Sara Jacobs (Calif.), Seth Magaziner (R.I.), Seth Moulton (Mass.), Chris Pappas (N.H.), Dina Titus (Nev.) and Rashida Tlaib (Mich.) wrote to Comer … Of the seven, Tlaib is the lone member of the Oversight panel. The Hill has requested comment from the office of Comer, the committee’s chair since January 2023.”
-
-
Reps. Foushee And Tonko Lead Push To Hold Gambling Industry CEOs Accountable For Social Harms Affecting Young Americans (press release): Today, Congresswoman Valerie Foushee (NC-04) and Congressman Paul D. Tonko (NY-20), alongside bicameral lawmakers, sent a letter to the CEOs of several sports-betting and prediction market companies urging them to take immediate action to address the growing normalization of online gambling and the harms these platforms pose for young Americans. The letter follows recently published research from Common Sense Media highlighting the need for lawmakers to act to protect young adults and kids from the significant risks associated with the rise of online gaming and betting.
-
“We are particularly alarmed by the rapid normalization of online gambling among younger Americans and the targeting of this demographic through predatory advertising,” the lawmakers wrote. “Aggressive advertising campaigns, coupled with partnerships between prediction markets and major media outlets––including CNN, CNBC, Dow Jones, and Yahoo Finance––have made it easier for younger Americans to fall victim to a culture of ‘everything is gambling.’” …
-
The letter was sent to the CEOs of ten companies across the sports-betting and prediction market industries. The companies that received the letter were Bet365 Group Limited, BetMGM Inc., FanDuel Group, Fanatics Inc., Caesars Entertainment, SidePrize LLC, DraftKings Inc. Polymarket, Kalshi Inc., and Robinhood Markets Inc.
-
The letter demands written responses from the companies, including:
-
Disclosure of any regulatory action, fines, or settlements that have been brought related to underage access, predatory advertising, or consumer protection violations.
-
Transparency around user demographics including what percentage of active users are between the ages of 18 and 24, and how much revenue is generated by users in that age group.
-
Clarification of what safeguards are currently in place by the companies to prevent access by individuals under the age of 18.
-
Internal policies governing the placement of advertisements on these platforms with substantial under-21 audiences.
-
-
🔍 Interest from Congress in prediction markets continues to grow. It still remains to be seen if any of this will be more than noise and turn into actual action. Reminder that we’re getting a Senate subcommittee hearing next week.
-
⚖️ Legal and regulatory news
-
-
More from Bloomberg: “A tribal nation is likely to succeed in blocking Kalshi from offering sports contracts on its land, a federal judge said in what appears to be the first ruling of its kind against the prediction market operator.
The Ho-Chunk Nation, a federally recognized Native American tribe, can move ahead with its lawsuit accusing the company of violating the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act, or IGRA, and has shown ‘a likelihood of success’ in its complaint, US District Judge William M. Conley in Madison, Wisconsin, wrote in a ruling Monday.”
-
-
Kalshi Will Return to Ninth Circuit, This Time Against Arizona (Bloomberg Law): “Kalshi Inc. will again go before an appellate court where prediction market providers have endured tough questioning over whether sports offerings were gambling subject to state oversight. Kalshi told the US District Court for the District of Arizona May 8 that it was appealing its April denial of a preliminary injunction against Arizona officials cracking down on its prediction markets.”
-
AG Coleman: Kentucky Has Jurisdiction to Regulate Sports Betting on Prediction Markets (press release): On the heels of the 152nd Kentucky Derby, Attorney General Russell Coleman stood up for the Commonwealth’s ability to regulate sports betting on prediction market platforms like Kalshi and Polymarket. In a letter to the Chairman of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), a bipartisan majority of state AGs argued that the CFTC lacks jurisdiction over the platforms’ sports-related contracts.
-
Prediction markets are platforms where users trade contracts on the outcome of future events. The platforms allow users to place wagers on game winners, point spreads and player statistics, bypassing the consumer protections and tax requirements mandated by state gambling laws. The AGs argue these so-called “event contracts” are no different from traditional sports wagering, such as those regulated by Kentucky’s Horse Racing and Gaming Corporation.
-
The Commonwealth of Kentucky has been setting rules for sports betting since well before the CFTC was created by Congress in 1974. The General Assembly created the first Kentucky Racing Commission in 1906 “to regulate the racing of running horses in the Commonwealth.” In their letter, the attorneys general underscore how states have the tools to set guardrails for sports betting and to protect users from problem gaming.
-
“There’s not a dollar’s worth of difference between prediction markets’ sports contracts and sports betting, and Kentucky has the jurisdiction and the responsibility to set the rules of the road,” said Attorney General Coleman. “Along with nearly every other AG in the country, we’re asking the federal government to recognize that states like Kentucky are well-positioned to protect our people, just like we have been doing for over a century.”
-
🔍 That’s cool and all, but the question still comes down to what the courts (and really just the Supreme Court) ultimately decide on federal preemption. Regimes to regulate prediction markets would only matter after all that. However, some people do think there’s an argument for taxing prediction markets in the near-term while not trying to regulate them.
-
Care to Predict What Happens? Kentucky’s New Prediction Markets Tax (JD Supra): “The tax created by HB 757 is, on its face, extremely broad. Yes, it is written to capture any prediction contract purchased within the state border of Kentucky, BUT, as written, it subjects to tax any prediction contract involving a Kentucky resident occurring anywhere — no border limitation language was enacted addressing transactions involving Kentucky residents.”
-
-
-
Pennsylvania Bill Would Regulate Prediction Markets Under PGCB Oversight (Play Pennsylvania): “Rep. Danilo Burgos has officially introduced legislation that would regulate prediction markets under the oversight of the Pennsylvania Gaming Control Board, as lawmakers continue pushing back against federally regulated event contract platforms acting as Pennsylvania sportsbooks. House Bill 2497, introduced Friday and referred to the House Gaming Oversight Committee, would create a new section of Pennsylvania gaming law dedicated to ‘event outcome prediction wagering.’”
-
New York takes aim at prediction markets with ‘risky bet’ campaign (SBC Americas): “The New York State Gaming Commission (NYSGC) has launched a new campaign to educate residents and visitors about the risks associated with unlawful gambling. On Friday, the NYSGC launched its Unlawful Gambling = Risky Bets initiative, providing bettors in the Empire State with the knowledge and tools to identify unlicensed gambling platforms and protect themselves from the dangers of unlawful wagering.”
-
From the NYSGC: “Everything else—online casinos (including ones that claim they are sweepstakes), prediction markets, offshore sites, etc. – is unlawful in New York State.”
-
🤔 Is it actually illegal? Well, that remains an open question in federal court. New York clearly believes it is.
-
-
‘Groundbreaking’ prediction market ETFs launch delayed again as SEC reviews more: analyst (The Block): “The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission is taking more time to review prediction market ETFs that were expected to launch on Monday, according to Eric Balchunas, a senior ETF analyst with Bloomberg Intelligence.”
-
“Prediction market ETFs delayed again, not launching today as planned,” Balchunas wrote in a post to X. “SEC wants to look at them a bit more. Doesn’t sound lethal, just more double checking disclosures.”
-
📣 Industry news
-
ForecastEx Seems To Be First To Quit On Sports Event Contracts (InGame): “It looks like ForecastEx has become the first Commodity Futures Trading Commission-registered exchange to throw in the towel on sports event contracts, as the prediction market has not offered any contracts on sports for 10 weeks. ForecastEx stopped its sports contracts the same way it self-certified and launched them: quietly, with nobody noticing until weeks later.”
-
DraftKings now has combos: After teasing that combos (aka parlays) were coming during Q1 earnings, now they are live. What it looks like on desktop:
-
MoonPay Acquires Dawn Labs, Launches AI Trading Copilot for Prediction Markets (Decrypt): “MoonPay is expanding further into AI-powered cryptocurrency infrastructure with the acquisition of Dawn Labs, a startup building autonomous trading tools for prediction markets and digital asset traders. The crypto payments company said Monday that it acquired the applied research lab and launched Dawn CLI, an AI-native trading product designed to let users build and execute trading strategies using natural language prompts.”
📖 Everything else you should know/read
-
Betting on War: The Legality and Lethality of Prediction Markets (Ink Stick Media): “When James couldn’t find a sporting match to wager on, he placed money on whether the Supreme Leader of Iran would keep his job. US President Donald Trump had a long history of threatening Iran, and the US military had previously attacked Iranian nuclear facilities in summer 2025.”
-
Polymarket is featured on Major League Baseball content here.
-
Selig the Joker: When the CFTC Chair Becomes the Punchline (John Lothian News): “The CFTC, at its best, is a small, technical, fiercely independent agency that referees the most important price-discovery markets on earth. It earned that role over fifty years of careful, often bipartisan, often unglamorous work. Michael Selig inherited that institution. So far, he is eroding the CFTC’s credibility in the Senate, among state attorneys general, gaming commissions, and tribes, and increasingly among FCMs and exchanges that thought the CFTC was on their side.”
-
Washington’s End-Run Around Sports Betting Laws (Commonplace): “Let’s be plain about it: offering “event contracts” on the outcome of a football game or on how many points LeBron James will score is not financial innovation. It is sports betting. Calling it anything else is a linguistic trick designed to evade the rules that govern gambling in the United States.”
-
Written by Mick Mulvaney, former Chief of Staff to President Trump, and Executive Director of Gambling is Not Investing
-
-
Can the U.S. Rein in Prediction Markets? (NY Times, podcast)