Ripple's chief legal officer argued that rulemaking on Regulation Crypto Assets would remain effective regardless of changes in agency leadership.
Do you trust that crypto rules written by regulators will last after leadership changes?
Ripple's chief legal officer, Stuart Alderoty, argued that formal crypto rulemaking outlasts changes in SEC leadership. Ripple submitted a comment letter to the SEC on the proposed Regulation Crypto Assets on October 20, 2026, supporting the rulemaking path with caveats and calling for refinements.
Why it matters
Formal rulemaking requires an agency to propose written rules, take public feedback and finalize them, while case-by-case enforcement lets policy emerge from whichever firms the agency chooses to sue. For crypto companies and the broader U.S. market, the choice between these approaches shapes how durable the rules will be.
Ripple's comment letter and public statements are the primary evidence cited, along with the company's spending of over $150 million on regulatory clarity efforts since 2020. Whether the SEC will adopt Ripple's suggested refinements remains unresolved.
The players
Ripple is a blockchain payments company whose legal battles over the status of XRP have made it a central participant in U.S. crypto regulation debates.
Stuart Alderoty is Ripple's chief legal officer and a prominent voice in the company's advocacy on crypto rulemaking.
Elizabeth Warren is a U.S. senator from Massachusetts known for her strong oversight of the cryptocurrency industry and financial regulators.
The details
Alderoty spoke at the Capitol Crypto Forum on November 19, 2026, arguing that formal rules remain in place even as agency leaders change. He also predicted increased congressional oversight if Sen. Elizabeth Warren gains more influence.
Timeline
-
2023: A federal court ruled that XRP is not a security.
-
Since 2020: Ripple has spent over $150 million on regulatory clarity efforts.
-
March 2026: SEC and CFTC joint guidance classified XRP as a digital commodity.
-
October 20, 2026: Ripple submitted its comment letter to the SEC on Regulation Crypto Assets.
-
November 19, 2026: Alderoty spoke at the Capitol Crypto Forum.
Legal Context
Ripple's position reflects a broader debate over whether the SEC should set crypto rules through formal proposals like Regulation Crypto Assets or through enforcement cases. The 2023 federal court ruling that XRP is not a security and the March 2026 SEC and CFTC guidance classifying it as a digital commodity show how the legal treatment of the token has shifted.
Whether crypto rules are set through formal rulemaking or through enforcement affects how predictable the rules are for investors and firms using digital assets. Rules adopted through a public process are harder to reverse with a change in agency leadership than policies built case by case.
The takeaway
Formal rulemaking gives crypto companies and investors a more stable framework than enforcement cases alone, which is why the process matters even when agency leadership changes.
Further reading
For more on how these rules are made and enforced, see Law coverage across U.S. politics.